Lost in the Weed

Lost in the Weed

We stopped subsidizing tobacco farming. The result? Tobacco farming’s on the rise.

Posted Tuesday, June 30, 2009 - 3:51pm

And the competition seems to be working exactly how the Philip Morris twins intended. In Kentucky, 85 percent of burley tobacco, the main kind of tobacco found in cigarettes, is exported. Burley tobacco has a harsh taste that has to be masked by flavors like cherry and vanilla—flavors that were just banned under the 2009 legislation. Tobacco growers, in other words, won't have much of a domestic market—but they will have a buyer trying to meet ever-growing foreign demand in Philip Morris International. That's why exports are rising and tobacco is one of the biggest export cash crops in the United States today. The whole scheme could be considered a blow to the idea that farmers need any government price supports at all.

So, five years later, the first prong of the tobacco legislation effort spearheaded by Philip Morris USA and supported by the Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids has consolidated, boosted, and industrialized American tobacco farming and removed the price supports that made American tobacco exports unattractive on the open market. The only problem is that now that Philip Morris International is using so much American tobacco, its profits had fallen last quarter due to the stronger American dollar. But before some congressman jumps to Big Tobacco's rescue, as they seem to love to do these days, I should note that the dollar is already weakening once again.

  • Paul Smalera has written for Condé Nast Portfolio, The New York Times and The New York Observer among others. He blogs at true/slant.
Photograph of a tobacco field by Tom Brakefield/Stockbyte/Getty Creative Images.
  • Comment Comment
  • RSS RSS

Comments

  • 1 Total
  • • Pending Comments 0
  • Login or register to post comments

subsidies

Did anyone really believe that removing subsidies was going to slow down anything? I can't think of an example where subsidies truly helped. Amtrak shouldn't be subsidized nor should any farming operation. If you can't make your business work on your own then it should fail. We should also remove all tax deductions (subsidies) and lower all tax rates or use a flat tax. No one should ever have to guess how much they owe in taxes.

Read more comments