What Ever Happened to the Live Album?

What Ever Happened to the Live Album?

Web video has made recorded concert albums nearly obsolete.

Posted Thursday, May 21, 2009 - 10:58pm

When Peter Frampton stepped onto the stage of the Marin County Civic Center in June of 1975, he was a niche taste, a pink-haired, baby-faced guitarist writing mellow songs after his stint with the noisier Humble Pie. He'd released three solo albums, none of which could be called a commercial smash; most casual music fans had never heard of him.

But he toured ardently and frequently, and the executives at his record label, A&M, knew that audiences responded to Frampton more passionately than record buyers. So they recorded that show and a few others throughout the year and then, in January 1976, released Frampton Comes Alive!, a double album that would end up going platinum six times. In a matter of months, millions of people knew Frampton's songs; the record sold 16 million copies worldwide, and it took more than 30 years for someone (and not even a rock star, but Garth Brooks) to release a more popular live album. 

The live rock and roll album was once a prized way to break a little-known musical act into the spotlight; it worked for Cheap Trick and Talking Heads, too. These days, though, live albums are never breakthroughs, and almost always released by already established bands. Last week, Coldplay announced that it won't even bother to sell its new live album, LeftRightLeftRightLeft. Instead, it will be offered as a free download on the weepy British rock band's Web site.

So who killed the live album as a cultural, musical, and commercial tour de force? One of the primary culprits has to be Web video. Once upon a time, even Grateful Dead fans had to sneak their recording devices into the Hartford Civic Center. Today, all it takes is an iPhone, Flip video camera, or even the cheapest of cell phones to record a show and, with a few clicks, send it to friends, upload it to YouTube, and share it with the entire world.

We are all bootleggers now.

Not convinced? Then go to YouTube and type in the name of a concert you've recently seen. If you've not been to a show recently—preferably one with lots of people under the age of, say, 35—try typing in "Yeah Yeah Yeahs at Coachella" and see what turns up: 262 clips from the rock band's afternoon show at the hip music festival held in the California desert last month. True, the audio isn't soundboard quality. But some clips aren't so bad-and many certainly compare favorably with the cassettes Deadheads used to barter for with tie-dyes, mushrooms, and other miracles.

Album cover for Frampton Comes Alive!

Comments

  • 6 Total
  • • Pending Comments 0
  • Login or register to post comments

I enjoyed the editorial. It

I enjoyed the editorial. It is very appealing. Thank you for the information. I will be back.

A Great Live Album

My favorite live album of all time: Alice In Chains Unplugged.

Before I heard it, I didn't really like Alice.

Most of their studio albums are overproduced and stuck in the "heavy metal" genre. They sound like bad Metallica imitations (and Metallica is already pretty bad!).

A couple of years ago, though, I heard the Unplugged album in a grass bar in Amsterdam, and it blew me away. The beauty of the songs, the expressiveness of the singing, and the band's musicianship . . . it's right up there with Nirvana's more famous Unplugged. And it's especially chilling and poignant now that Layne Staley, Alice's lead singer, is dead.

Highly recommended, even if you THINK you don't like this band.

Agree wholeheartedly on the

Agree wholeheartedly on the Alice unplugged album. It's excellent, and the DVD of the concert is also quote nice if you're into watching bands play. In that same vein, I'd suggest checking out Tesla's "Five Man Acoustical Jam." Tesla is something of a B-grade a hard rock act with a handful of hits (most notably "Love Song") and above-average songwriting ability. This acoustic live album spawned their other significant radio hit, an acoustic cover of the Five Man Electrical Band's hit "Signs." It's nice to watch a band pull the plug on their instruments and prove that they can entertain an audience the old fashioned way. Shows that the songs are still satisfyingly hummable when stripped to their bare essence. And it's great to watch the guitarists flexing their chops on steel string guitars, mining their instruments for new colors and tones without the benefit/crutch of amplification and distortion. The extended instrumental passages on the album are some of its best bits.

Live Albums

There are two kinds of live albums:

1) Greatest Hits - Some live albums sell decently because they are basically another way of packaging a greatest hits collection. I'm thinking of albums such as Rush's "Exit Stage Left," Sarah Mclachlan's "Mirrorball" or Fleetwood Mac's "The Dance." On all three of these albums the track selection is excellent and the musicianship is superb, but the songs are mostly carbon copies of the album tracks. Yes there are some differences: the guitar on "A Passage to Bangkok" is fuzzier and meaner than the original Rush album track, the songs on "Mirrorball" have a slightly edgier sound than Mclahlans' original compositions, and Stevie Nicks adds a moving new intro to "Rhiannon" but by and large these are the favorites with which we are intimately familiar.

2) A whole new take - Some live albums sell well because they bring us a whole new take on the songs we've come to love. No doubt much of the success of Led Zeppelin's "Soundtrack to The Song Remains the Same" is the brilliant 26 minute version of "Dazed and Confused" that spans a whole album side.

I had a point to make... but forgot what it was. Oh well.

Live albums

The biggest reason that live albums are obsolete is because most bands aren't good enough musically to play good concerts anymore. The majority of the music audience stopped caring about musical competence over 20 years ago.

Live Albums

Thelonious is exactly right. Bands that are good enough to sound great in concert still release live albums. RUSH is an excellent example of this. I believe they release a live album after every concert tour.

Read more comments