Van Jones: The Face of Green Jobs
Meet Obama’s environmental evangelist.
Years before it was announced that Van Jones, the premier green-jobs advocate in the country, was headed to the White House, it was clear that Van Jones was headed to the White House. Thomas Friedman devoted an entire 2007 column to Jones, writing of his lofty goals, "I would not underestimate him." Jones muscled his way through Congress to get a Green Jobs Act passed in 2007 and then lavished praise on Nancy Pelosi and now-Labor Secretary, then-Rep. Hilda Solis. Pelosi returned the favor with a rave book blurb for Jones' 2008 best-seller The Green Collar Economy, writing that Jones possessed "sparkling intelligence, powerful vision, and deep empathy." When he wasn't running his fix-poverty, fix-the-planet nonprofit in Oakland, Calif., he was seeding Obama's transition team with ideas for an all-encompassing environmental/labor/energy/
So despite originally saying he had no interest in moving to Washington, Jones is now part of the executive branch. Officially, he's the "special adviser for green jobs, enterprise, and innovation," a clunky title unbefitting of a man so who's especially talented at turning a phrase. Basically, he's Obama's green-jobs guy. But he's the green-jobs guy who used to be the green-jobs advocate. When I spent the day with him in Washington last week, Jones told me he sees the transition as one of "inspiration to implementation." It's a slogan that summarizes not just Jones' challenge but the whole administration's. The trouble for both: Inspiration is the easy part.
Jones is the switchboard operator for Obama's grand vision of the American economy; connecting the phone lines between all the federal agencies invested in a green economy. The $787 billion stimulus Congress authorized in February had at least $30 billion of green-jobs funding attached to it. It's Jones' responsibility to work within all the government agencies to make sure it gets doled out appropriately. Obama wants a cap-and-trade policy that will eventually force American industry to develop new green technologies that will lead to new green jobs. It's Jones' task to convince the American people that this is a good idea. The administration will have to get employees of dirty-energy companies—companies Jones calls the "pro-polluter status quo"—to believe they'll have jobs in a green economy, too. It's for Jones to sculpt that messaging operation. Jones told me the one thing he's learned in the four weeks he's been in Washington is that "power in D.C. is an illusion. Nobody in D.C. has as much power as they want—not even the president." Maybe Jones should lend Obama some of his.
Van Jones loves Barack Obama. As far back as 2004, he was calling Obama a "hero." These days, it's rare for Jones to go 20 minutes without mentioning his boss's brilliance. Jones compared the president to Michael Jordan—twice. (Obama is just going to keep scoring until somebody makes him stop.) Jones couldn't stop raving about the "extraordinary" speech Obama gave about the economy at Georgetown last week; he was "so proud of him" for giving it. His 4-and-a-half-year-old son calls the president "Baracko" and for a long time thought "Barack Obama Joe Biden" was the name of one person. Jones tells that last anecdote with an especially gleeful tone—it combines his real family with his new one.
Jones' crush on Obama is partly authentic and partly occupational. He has become the administration's chief spokesperson for all things green-economy. It's a mark of the strange nature of Jones' job that he has to be a switchboard operator who talks as much as he listens. While I was with him, the press person for the Council on Environmental Quality—the executive committee for which Jones works—repeatedly talked with Jones about the media hits coming up. There was loose chatter about Anderson Cooper, Larry King, and other spots rumored for the weekend. CNN was thinking of following him to a speaking gig in California. I accompanied him to a green-jobs-are-the-future talk he gave to business journalists. Directly afterward, he took a cab to the airport to go to Massachusetts, where he did the same thing for a bunch of college students. His job has become an institutionalized, more regimented, version of what he was already doing outside the administration: speaking Obama's praises. It's one that Jones says takes up only 15 percent of the time, but it appeared to be more like 50 percent.
This spokesperson role is largely why the administration brought him into the fold in the first place. It had two options: 1) let Jones compliment the policies from the outside, lending it credibility within the activist community, or 2) bring Jones inside and give him the authority to evangelize to a far larger audience—all of America—since Obama would probably already have grass-roots support. Option 2 it was.
And so started Jones' transformation from advocate to public servant. It's not an entirely smooth one; Jones and Obama don't agree on everything. Yes, Obama's environmental, energy, economic, and labor policies have been influenced by Jones and other progressives' work. But in the past, Jones has been a loud supporter of green jobs because they have the chance to help raise people of color out of poverty. In his book, he warns of an "eco-apartheid": a situation in which people of color are left behind as green jobs and green benefits all go to the privileged. But in official Washington, rhetoric about the middle class is always preferable to talking about poor people. In the day I spent with Jones, I heard him mention the disadvantaged only twice. I asked him why he wasn't speaking more about using green jobs for the poor. He offered a knowing smile and said, "We need an economy first."
Otherwise, the friction comes from which energy sources qualify as green. Obama is more supportive of clean coal and ethanol than Jones. (Jones on clean coal: "We could power the country with clean coal, or we could have unicorns pull our cars for us." Jones on ethanol: "One hundred percent against corn-based ethanol. Corn should be food and not fuel.") It's a tension that is acknowledged within the government. When discussing the administration's party line on cap-and-trade, Jones told an advocacy group all the usual talking points but left out a willingness to work with clean-coal and ethanol producers. The communications strategist chimed in saying that she knows it's not Jones' favorite part of the message, but advocacy groups can also say that the government believes in having a "diverse portfolio" of publically funded green energy and green jobs. Jones simply smiled.
Later, when I asked him how he rectifies his own beliefs with the party line, he said that when he's talking about green jobs these days, he has one overriding thought: "What would Barack Obama say?" Jones may still be learning Washington, but he already knows how to be on message. (So much so that while I was with him, he started a speech off with the strained declaration that there was no economic stimulus in this country. There was only the American Economic and Reinvestment Act. Tomatoes, tom-ah-toes. Just don't call the whole thing off.) He told me that the definitions of what was and wasn't a green job were still being hashed out, and would likely be defined not just by the feds but by state and local governments as well, since they'll have their own green-job money to spend. It was an artful dodge that I could imagine Obama performing. On-message yet again.
By buying into the administration's rhetoric, Jones runs the risk of sounding like a talking head. But he manages to avoid that ignominy by exhibiting a rare quality in Washington: He's a storyteller. To Jones, there's an analogy, allusion, or alliteration awaiting every complex explanation of geothermal energy and photovoltaic cells. He has an honest sense of humor—no sarcasm and no biting insults—that puts people at ease with the scary reality that the economy-as-we-know-it is going to have to change. During a speech about why we must start making polluters pay for carbon emissions—a key piece of the president's cap-and-trade agenda—he told a story of a man being charged a fine for throwing a gum wrapper on the sidewalk. If we're doing it for crap, we should be doing it for carbon. When he puts it that way, it makes a surprising amount of sense.
The man is a sound-bite vending machine. Some other Vanisms from our day together:
- "This dollar is working double-time, triple-time, overtime."—On how green-jobs funding infiltrates an economy in multiple sectors.
- "It used to be that we were the No. 1 economy in the world because we were the No. 1 producers. Somehow we got it into our minds that we could be the No. 1 consumers."—On the need to transition out of our current economic system.
- "And so we started going from bubble to bust to bailout to bubble."—On the last 20 years.
- "The president doesn't want a bunch of solar sweatshops."—On the risks of green jobs being low-level, low-paying labor.
- "It's a long and winding road from the president signing a bill into law and signing the back of a paycheck."—On the hurdles of actually getting green-job stimulus money into Americans' bank accounts.
He speaks with a gentle voice most of the time, but every now and then he explodes for dramatic effect. When discussing why the specifics of cap-and-trade confuse Americans, he put on the voice of a dumb child and in a very loud, singsongy voice said, "I am confuse-ed." This was in a meeting with four people he had just met. During another meeting with new acquaintances, he pronounced the word million as if he were Dr. Evil from an old Austin Powers movie. When I asked him about a Spanish report saying that for every five jobs Spain created, it lost nine, Jones started guffawing. "El reporto bogus-o!" he cackled and repeated over and over. The leader of our potential green-jobs revolution has, at times, the disarming sense of humor of a 12-year-old boy.
Of course, all of this is the inspiration part of the equation. But it affects the implementation as well. In a messaging meeting with the Union of Concerned Scientists and some other Obama colleagues, it was clear who the UCS was here to see. His reputation as a package artist precedes him, and the reps from UCS went straight to Jones with the hard questions they were hearing out in the field. What do you say to people who think the transition can't be done? "You don't think we can do this? You don't think America can rise to this challenge? Oh, yes we can!" What do you say to coal miners whose jobs might be lost in a green economy? "The coal miners are heroes, and we've been forcing them to blow up their grandmothers' mountains?!" Let's give them jobs putting wind turbines on top of their mountains, he continued. What do you say to people who are afraid the costs are going to go up? Talk about the Clean Air Act, which was expected to cost $1,500 per ton of emissions for big business. "American business did not pay $1,500 per ton. They didn't pay $1,000 per ton. They didn't pay $500 per ton. They paid $250 per ton. One-sixth of what was expected." Competition would drive down prices, he swore. (Later, I asked how, given that energy companies often operate local monopolies: There's nobody else who can supply my home's energy. How would prices go down without competition? He didn't have a satisfactory answer.) It was Jones' rhetorical skill being put to use; from there, UCS could use Jones' packaging as a way to implement policy.
Jones swears that he spends most of his time being a strict implementer, listening to what the rest of government has to say. He says people from many different departments—energy, labor, housing and urban development, environmental protection—work on different pieces of the green-jobs portfolio. He sees his role as being a Gladwell-ian connector, making sure that somebody in labor knows about somebody in energy and that he's happy to serve as a go-between.
I didn't see much of Jones' implementation in action, but the little I did see was promising. The first meeting I attended was between Jones, a few other Obama types, and representatives of a home-builders' association. They were subtly lobbying for green-jobs money, saying how great their training programs were and how much good they were doing in the industry. Jones, though, was a tough sell. He wanted to know how quickly they could ramp up training if given extra money, saying Obama's criteria for supplying retrofit money were that the jobs be done "effectively, fast, and fairly." One of the home-builders' reps didn't want to say that it would take him up to a year to build enough training centers to double the program's reach, but Jones kept pressing until he got the answer out of him. It was a polite exchange in the policy weeds, the place where almost everything in Washington does gets done.
The two sides of Jones' jobs are hard to reconcile, even for him. When I asked what, exactly, his job was, he didn't have a snappy answer, surprising for a man who thrives because of the way he contextualizes hard-to-understand concepts. Similarly, when I asked about the difference between an advocate and a political servant, he had to pause for a bit to collect his thoughts. It was as though he had spent so much time within the inspiration-implementation spectrum that he hadn't had any time for reflection.
But then, just as I got back from D.C. the next day, I had an e-mail waiting for me. It was Jones, who had summoned a way to frame his job. "I'm a community organizer inside the federal family," he wrote. Compared with my belabored switchboard metaphor, it was an inspiring way to put it.
(Photo of Van Jones by Vince Bucci/Getty Images)
RSS
Twitter
Comments
Van Jones is charismatic but
Van Jones is charismatic but is a man of very little substance upon getting to know him . He is the classic snake oil salesman , B.S. artist everyone has met at some point in life . It is not surprising he has charmed his way into the Administration in such a nebulous role . I do believe much more of his past will soon come out and befall him as he speaks in outrageous metaphors and hyperbole . Just wait and see what is yet to come....
Black man, green jobs, commie
Black man, green jobs, commie Red. Color the man gone. Van Jones...DLTDHYITAOYWO.
Green = Red
Van Jones - Noted racist (like his boss), Communist, and Truther. What a great combination.
Green jobs?
There is a serious disconnect between the liberals fantasies about "green" jobs and the reality. They imagine they will keep their jobs and that their families all get to keep their jobs and that somehow the "green" movement will make it all better. The reality is much different. First they pass their co2 legislation. Then the manufacturing and the jobs supporting manufacturing leave for other countries. Then shock sets in. This isn't what we expected. Stop! Bring our jobs back. Too late, sorry, you will have to wait for one of the new "green" jobs. Yes, we know it doesn't pay as well, but gee, we're saving the planet. You will just have to get used to the fact that you are going nowhere, but hey, it's okay. Obama and the politicians still have THEIR limos and jets. This is factual, the UN report is very clear that manufacturing is going to relocate to developing countries, but that is only fair. The US has had it's day in the sun, time for someone else to take a turn. But wait! How about the co2? Well, actually we just exported the co2 AND the jobs to other countries, so we didn't actually get rid of it, we just sent it overseas. But this is what you voted for, don't forget that when your life is turned upside down. But don't worry, the midterms are in 2010 and by then the truth just might be sinking in. Just maybe enough people will clear their brains enough to vote to keep our jobs.
Great Article
Like everybody else, I have a high level of respect for Mr. Jones, but as pointed out in this article, he often comes across as a racist.
That may seem to be a strong word, but in an interview about the woman that will be replacing him as head of the Green Jobs for All organization, Mr Jones is quoted as saying " she's a very capable African American woman"
I'm not sure, but if I were to describe my replacement as a capable white guy, I would be vilified by the AA community.
The montra of the green movement is "think globally, act locally" Perhaps Mr Jones should start realizing that he is now part of the global stage and that the people he represents are of all colors and economic backgrounds.
Green Jobs for All- race not important
http://www.mygreenscene.com